Skip to content
Plinth

· Private foundation

Williams Foundation

Its FY2024 filing reports that it funds preselected organizations and did not take unsolicited requests; check the foundation's own site before ruling it out.

$1.0M
Granted FY2024still arriving
47
Grants FY2024still arriving
6
States reached
$100k
Largest
01What you fund
0197% classified

What you funded, over time

Every grant placed by its stated purpose and the recipient’s mission, by year — across FY20172024.

Education$1.4MHealth$858kHuman Services$827kArts & Culture$818kReligion$328kYouth Development$322kRecreation & Sports$321kFood & Nutrition$289kOther$0
02FY2024 · 47 grants

Where the money goes

Your grants by size, and where they go.

By grant size · FY2024

  • Under $10k14 grants · $46k
  • $10k–50k28 grants · $599k
  • $50k–250k5 grants · $400k
$15,000
Median grant
6
States reached
$12M
Total assets
Largest grants
RecipientAmount
CINCINNATI CANCER ADVISORS$100,000
PROKIDS$100,000
THE CHILDREN'S THEATRE OF CINCINNATI$100,000
MEALS ON WHEELS OF SOUTHWEST OHIO & NKY$50,000
Individual grant recipient$50,000
Individual grant recipient$48,333
TAFT MUSEUM OF ART$42,000
TALBERT HOUSE$37,000
MATTHEW 25 MINISTRIES$35,000
CHILDREN'S HOME OF CINCINNATI DBA BEST POINT$30,000
ARTSWAVE$27,000
ST XAVIER CHURCH$25,000
UNITED WAY$25,000
CINCINNATI BALLET$25,000
ST VINCENT DE PAUL$25,000
02The need
03

Do your dollars go where the need is?

Each grant placed by the hardship in its grantee’s ZIP, then read against the area’s typical level.

show:

Your human-services grants (FY17–24, $664k) land where the poverty rate runs at 16%, against an area that typically sits at 10%. 99% of those dollars go to grantees based in above-average-need neighborhoods. Most of your grants land in higher-need ZIPs.

area typical 10%CHOSEN & DEARLY LOVED FOUNDATION: $3k → 9%CHOSEN & DEARLY LOVED FOUNDATION: $3k → 9%CHOSEN & DEARLY LOVED FOUNDATION: $3k → 9%ONESOURCE: $1k → 16%TALBERT HOUSE: $37k → 16%FIRST STEP HOME: $30k → 16%TALBERT HOUSE: $30k → 16%LIGHTHOUSE YOUTH SERVICES: $25k → 16%Lighthouse Youth Services: $25k → 16%TALBERT HOUSE: $23k → 16%FIRST STEP HOME: $18k → 16%FIRST STEP HOME: $15k → 16%FIRST STEP HOME: $10k → 16%FIRST STEP HOME: $8k → 16%ST MARGARET HALL: $5k → 16%FIRST STEP HOME: $5k → 16%ST MARGARET HALL: $4k → 16%ST MARGARET HALL: $4k → 16%ST MARGARET HALL: $3k → 16%THE CHILDREN'S HOME: $78k → 16%THE CHILDREN'S HOME: $65k → 16%CHILDREN'S HOME: $60k → 16%THE CHILDREN'S HOME: $58k → 16%THE CHILDREN'S HOME: $33k → 16%PREGNANCY CENTER EAST: $30k → 16%BEST POINT EDUCATION AND BEHAVIORAL HEALTH: $10k → 16%CHILDREN'S HOME: $8k → 16%CINCINNATI SQUASH ACADEMY: $500 → 16%LADD: $8k → 16%LIVING ARRANGMENT FOR THE DEVELOPMENTALLY DISABLED: $5k → 16%EVERY CHILD SUCCEEDS: $3k → 16%LADD: $1k → 16%LIVING ARRANGEMENT FOR THE DEVELOPMENTAL DISABLED: $1k → 16%STEPPING STONES: $10k → 16%COMMUNITY MATTERS CINCINNATI INC: $10k → 16%BEECH ACRES PARENTING CENTER: $5k → 16%PREGNANCY CENTER EAST: $5k → 16%PREGNANCY CENTER EAST: $5k → 16%YMCA OF GREATER CINCINNATI: $7k → 16%YMCA OF GREATER CINCINNATI: $6k → 16%YMCA OF GREATER CINCINNATI: $4k → 16%YMCA OF GREATER CINCINNATI: $3k → 16%YMCA OF GREATER CINCINNATI: $3k → 16%0%20%40%50%more need →
grant to an above-average-need area below average· circle size = grant amount

Matched: human-services grants are those whose grantee’s IRS cause code is Human Services. Placed by people below the poverty linein the grantee’s ZIP, averaged from the tracts in that ZIP; grantee ZIP can differ from where services are delivered.

Which US states your grants reach

WA
IL
WI
MI
NY
MA
IN
OH
PA
CT
CO
KY
VA
TN
NC
SC
DC
AL
GA
FL

US grants placed by each grantee’s ZIP, which can differ from where services are actually delivered. Need from public data — U.S. Census/ACS, CDC PLACES, Eviction Lab, USDA — shown as context about the area, never attributed to your giving.

03Your edge
repeat funding

Who you back again

Which organizations you funded more than once, and which you funded a single time. Each grantee is matched to its own filings.

82%of every dollar goes to organizations you’ve funded before.
$5.2M · 79 repeat orgs$1.2M to everyone else

And the relationships you keep tend to grow: grantees you re-up on have seen median revenue of +25% since the first grant, against +17% for the ones you funded once.

79 repeat relationships — 29 still active in FY2024, 50 since wound down; 18 grantees were first funded in FY2024 (too recent to call).

How the two cohorts compare

Re-uppedFunded once

Organizations

79
69

Total granted

$5.2M
$774k

Median revenue growth · since first grant

+25%
+17%

Still filing today

59%
43%

New vs renewed · share of each year

In FY2024, 64% of grant dollars renewed an existing relationship; $380k went to new ones.

50%100%’17’18’19’20’21’22’23’24
RenewedFirst-time

Where new relationships form · theme of each grantee’s first grant

’17’18’19’20’21’22’23’24
Human ServicesHealthArts & CultureEducationCivil RightsRecreation & SportsOther

First-time = a grantee’s first year in your filing window; renewed = funded in an earlier year too. As a portfolio matures the renewed share naturally climbs — once funded, an org stays “renewable” — so the signal is the years that buck it (a new-grantee intake wave). The earliest year is left-censored: relationships that predate the data read as “new.” Theme is the grantee’s IRS cause.

Backed again, and grew

  • XU
    XAVIER UNIVERSITY
    5× · 2017–2021 · $950k · revenue +24%
  • TC
    The Children's Home of Cincinnati Ohio
    6× · 2018–2023 · $310k · revenue +44%
  • CI
    Cincinnati Institute of Fine Arts
    6× · 2017–2024 · $133k · revenue +2%

Funded once

  • TU
    THE UNIVERSITY OF CINCINNATI FOUNDATION
    one grant, 2022 · $100k · revenue +3%
  • CT
    CHILDREN'S THEATRE
    one grant, 2022 · $100k
  • BG
    BOYS & GIRLS CLUBS OF GREATER CINCINNATIgraduated
    one grant, 2021 · $58k · revenue +324%

Repeat = funded in two or more distinct years; growth and survival are read from each grantee’s own subsequent IRS filings.

04Your field

The map has a center of gravity: the average direction from the rest of the sector toward the organizations the foundation funds — the shape of its giving. Scoring every nonprofit along that direction surfaces the ones that look most like the portfolio. These are the closest matchesthat aren’t grantees — a resemblance in what they say they do, not a recommendation.

1
Cincinnati Usa Regional Chamber Foundation

To develop and promote economic development, talent initiatives and the unique offerings in the cincinnati region.

Community Improvement
2
Legal Aid Society of Cincinnati

To resolve serious legal problems of low income people, to promote economic and family stability, and reduce poverty through effective legal assistance.

3
The Contemporary Arts Center

The CAC is a lab for understanding ourselves, others, and the world around us through the experience and creation of all contemporary art forms.

Arts & Culture
4
Cincinnati Chamber Orchestra

Cincinnati Chamber Orchestra (CCO) creates intimate, transformative experiences that connect the musically curious.

Arts & Culture
5
Central Indiana Corporate Partnership Inc

Central indiana corporate partnership (cicp) is an alliance of indiana's business and research university leaders coming together to foster long-term prosperity for the region. cicp's mission is to transform the economy of indiana in order…

Community Improvement
6
Cintrifuse

To empower Cincinnati entrepreneurs to launch bold, scalable startups; and we work to improve the odds of those startups growing into transformational companies.

Community Improvement
7
Cincinnati Union Bethel

Empowering women to break the cycles of poverty, addiction, and human trafficking.

Human Services
8
Jewish Federation of Cincinnati

The Jewish Federation of Cincinnati develops and connects leaders, contributors, organizations, and ideas to build an inclusive Jewish community that helps people in need, supports Israel, and assures a vibrant Jewish future.

Philanthropy
9
Cincinnati Public Radio Inc

Cincinnati Public Radio is the trusted, independent source of journalism, music and culture empowering a vibrant, engaged and informed community.

Arts & Culture
10
Cincinnati Bar Association

To promote professional excellence, foster justice, serve our members and educate the public.

11
Children's Hospital Medical Center

Cincinnati children's hospital medical center will be the leader in improving child health. cincinnati children's will provide child health and transform delivery of care through fully integrated, globally recognized research, education,…

Health
12
Cincinnati Observatory Center

The mission of the cincinnati observatory is to maintain the integrity and heritage of an historic 19th century observatory and to educate, engage, and inspire our community about astronomy and science.

Arts & Culture

For reference, the grantee most central to the portfolio’s shape is The Greater Cincinnati Foundation and the most unlike its peers is Character & Courage Foundation. Resemblance is measured on each organization’s own IRS 990 mission text; it reflects how work is described, not its quality or impact.

For each theme you fund, this compares how the sector’s money is shifting with how your own giving is shifting.

← shrinkinggrowing →↓ leaning in → pulling backsteadyLocal History MuseumsSenior Support ServicesChild Abuse Advocacy Servic…Faith-Based Liberal Arts Co…Cancer Support ServicesChristian Youth CampsYouth Sports ProgramsPregnancy Support ServicesJewish Community Organizati…Environmental Conservation …Developmental Disabilities …Food Banks and PantriesCommunity College Foundatio…Youth Development CentersAddiction Recovery ServicesPolicy Research and AdvocacyCommunity Arts CentersSchool District FoundationsIndependent K-12 SchoolsCommunity Foundations
the sector your giving your giving is ahead of the sector the sector’s ahead of you· dot size = how much the theme matters to each side
Ordered by the change in your giving — leaning in on top, pulling back at the bottom. The bar between the two dots is how out of step you are with the sector. Hover any row for detail.

Sector change and giving change are each shown relative to their own range, growing (right) or shrinking (left); both normalized, so inflation isn’t mistaken for growth.

Your grantees are a median of 43 years old; the field is 18. You back the established end — and your money leans older still.

THE FIELDby orgYOUR GRANTEESby number19%2%<5yr14%4%5–10yr20%12%10–20yr21%21%20–35yr14%21%35–55yr13%39%55yr+
THE FIELDby orgYOUR MONEYby value19%1%<5yr14%5%5–10yr20%5%10–20yr21%16%20–35yr14%37%35–55yr13%36%55yr+

The field is 19% startups (under 5 years old) — 2% of your grantees by number, and just 1% of your money.

Closures · last 5 years

The orgs you fund almost never close 1.0% lost their exemption, against 11% of the field you don’t fund.

orgs you fund
1.0%1/101
the rest of the field
11%
2,962/26,612

Age = years since IRS exemption (a founding proxy). “Closed” = auto-revocation for 3 years of non-filing — a floor on closure, not proof, and bigger established orgs lapse least. Association, not causation.

04the grantee network

93 grantees tracked through their own filings, 2017–2025.

Each one resolved to its own IRS returns and tracked year by year — your grant beside their revenue from every source. Association, dated; never a causal claim.

Counted here: distinct organizations you funded across 20172025, not grant rows in a single year — so this will not match the grant count on the cover. 93 of the 169 grantees resolved in that span have returns of their own we could reconcile; the rest are funded organizations whose filings we could not track year by year.

0
Load-bearing (≥25% of a budget)
16
Early backer (in before they grew)
90/93
Grantees still filing
62/93
Grew since you first funded

Where your money sits — by cause, then by grantee

CISE FUND — $222,000 · OtherCISE FUNDReds Hall of Fame — $200,000 · OtherReds Hall of FameCINCINNATI CANCER ADVISORS — $200,000 · OtherCINCINNATI CANCER ADVISORSUNITED WAY — $180,000 · OtherUNITED WAYBOYS AND GIRLS CLUB OF GREATER — $154,750 · Other+101 more — $2,303,523 · Other+101 moreXAVIER UNIVERSITY — $950,000 · EducationXAVIER UNIVERSITYGEORGETOWN UNIVERSITY — $75,500 · EducationGEORGETOWN UNIVERSI…+9 more — $91,780 · Education+9 moreThe Children's Home of Cincinnati Ohio — $310,000 · Human ServicesThe Childre…TALBERT HOUSE — $89,500 · Human ServicesTALBERT HOU…THE FIRST STEP HOME INC — $85,500 · Human ServicesTHE FIRST S…LIGHTHOUSE YOUTH SERVICES — $50,000 · Human ServicesLIGHTHOUSE …PREGNANCY CENTER PLUS INC — $40,000 · Human ServicesPREGNANCY C…YWCA of Greater Cincinnati — $22,500 · Human Services+9 more — $66,500 · Human Services+9 moreTAFT MUSEUM OF ART — $158,000 · Arts & CultureTAFT MUSE…Cincinnati Institute of Fine Arts — $132,500 · Arts & CultureCincinnat…The Children's Theatre of Cincinnati — $100,000 · Arts & CultureThe Child…CINCINNATI MUSEUM ASSOCIATION — $80,000 · Arts & CultureCINCINNAT…The Cincinnati Ballet Company Inc — $35,000 · Arts & CultureThe Cinci…CINCINNATI SHAKESPEARE COMPANY — $20,000 · Arts & Culture+7 more — $25,250 · Arts & CultureCISE — $96,500 · ReligionENNIS TAIT MINISTRIES INC — $93,000 · ReligionBLOC MINISTRIES INC — $70,000 · ReligionCATHOLIC LEADERSHIP INSTITUTE — $50,000 · ReligionBEECHWOOD HOME — $108,500 · HealthInternational Rett Syndrome Foundation — $50,000 · HealthThe Karen Wellington Memorial Foundation — $37,500 · HealthTHE DRAGONFLY FOUNDATION — $25,000 · HealthMelanoma Know More — $15,000 · HealthMAY WE HELP INC — $15,000 · HealthThe Christ Hospital — $10,000 · Health+8 more — $28,750 · HealthProKids — $127,500 · Civil RightsAMERICAN JEWISH COMMITTEE — $15,000 · Civil RightsOHIO JUSTICE AND POLICY CENTER — $12,500 · Civil Rights+2 more — $5,000 · Civil Rights
Other$3,260,273Education$1,117,280Human Services$664,000Arts & Culture$550,750Religion$309,500Health$289,750Civil Rights$160,000

Each org by its size and your share of it — top-left is where you’re load-bearing

25%50%75%100%$100k$1.0M$10M$100Mgrantee revenue →↑ your share of their budgetXAVIER UNIVERSITY — $950,000 over 5y, 0.1% of budgetThe Children's Home of Cincinnati Ohio — $310,000 over 6y, 0.3% of budgetTAFT MUSEUM OF ART — $158,000 over 4y, 0.7% of budgetCincinnati Institute of Fine Arts — $132,500 over 6y, 0.3% of budgetProKids — $127,500 over 5y, 0.8% of budgetBEECHWOOD HOME — $108,500 over 5y, 0.4% of budgetFREESTORE FOODBANK INC — $106,000 over 4y, 0.1% of budgetTHE UNIVERSITY OF CINCINNATI FOUNDATION — $100,000 over 1y, 0.1% of budgetThe Children's Theatre of Cincinnati — $100,000 over 1y, 0.6% of budgetCISE — $96,500 over 3y, 0.4% of budgetENNIS TAIT MINISTRIES INC — $93,000 over 4y, 21% of budgetTALBERT HOUSE — $89,500 over 3y, 0.0% of budgetTHE FIRST STEP HOME INC — $85,500 over 6y, 0.5% of budgetMatthew 25 Ministries Inc — $81,000 over 3y, 0.0% of budgetCINCINNATI MUSEUM ASSOCIATION — $80,000 over 6y, 0.2% of budgetGEORGETOWN UNIVERSITY — $75,500 over 2y, 0.0% of budgetCAMPING AND EDUCATION FOUNDATION — $71,250 over 6y, 0.6% of budgetBLOC MINISTRIES INC — $70,000 over 3y, 0.9% of budgetCINCINNATI USA REGIONAL CHAMBER — $70,000 over 2y, 0.3% of budgetBOYS & GIRLS CLUBS OF GREATER CINCINNATI — $57,500 over 1y, 1.1% of budgetLA SOUPE INC — $51,500 over 2y, 0.9% of budgetInternational Rett Syndrome Foundation — $50,000 over 4y, 0.4% of budgetCATHOLIC LEADERSHIP INSTITUTE — $50,000 over 2y, 0.3% of budgetLIGHTHOUSE YOUTH SERVICES — $50,000 over 2y, 0.1% of budgetCINCINNATI CENTER CITY DEVELOPMENT CORP — $40,000 over 2y, 0.0% of budgetPREGNANCY CENTER PLUS INC — $40,000 over 3y, 2.1% of budgetThe Karen Wellington Memorial Foundation — $37,500 over 6y, 1.3% of budgetThe Cincinnati Ballet Company Inc — $35,000 over 2y, 0.2% of budget4C For Children Inc — $30,000 over 1y, 0.6% of budgetINDIAN HILL FOUNDATION — $26,000 over 2y, 1.7% of budgetLevel Up Cincinnati — $25,000 over 1y, 11% of budgetEaster Seals Tristate — $25,000 over 1y, 0.1% of budgetCINCINNATI GOLDEN GLOVES FOR YOUTH — $25,000 over 1y, 6.9% of budgetTHE DRAGONFLY FOUNDATION — $25,000 over 1y, 1.1% of budgetYWCA of Greater Cincinnati — $22,500 over 5y, 0.1% of budgetTHE CINCINNATI REDS COMMUNITY FUND — $20,000 over 1y, 0.7% of budgetHOSPICE OF CINCINNATI INCORPORATED — $20,000 over 1y, 0.0% of budgetTHE CHATFIELD EDGE — $18,500 over 3y, 0.1% of budgetMelanoma Know More — $15,000 over 3y, 3.3% of budgetST MARGARET HALL — $15,000 over 4y, 0.1% of budgetTri-State Trails dba CROWN Cincinnati — $15,000 over 1y, 1.0% of budgetAMERICAN JEWISH COMMITTEE — $15,000 over 2y, 0.0% of budgetMAY WE HELP INC — $15,000 over 2y, 2.0% of budgetTHE GREATER CINCINNATI FOUNDATION — $14,599 over 1y, 0.0% of budgetLiving Arrangements for the Developmentally Disabled Inc — $14,500 over 4y, 0.1% of budgetOHIO JUSTICE AND POLICY CENTER — $12,500 over 3y, 0.5% of budgetThe Christ Hospital — $10,000 over 1y, 0.0% of budgetTHE FILMMAKERS COLLABORATIVE INC — $10,000 over 1y, 0.2% of budget
Go grantee by grantee — a decade per org, and how each moved after you funded them

A decade per grantee — revenue shaded, your grants as bars, all rows on one timeline.

  • Who funds XAVIER UNIVERSITY
  • Who funds The Children's Home of Cincinnati Ohio
  • Who funds TAFT MUSEUM OF ART
  • Who funds Cincinnati Institute of Fine Arts
  • Who funds ProKids
  • Who funds BEECHWOOD HOME
  • Who funds FREESTORE FOODBANK INC
  • Who funds THE UNIVERSITY OF CINCINNATI FOUNDATION
  • Who funds The Children's Theatre of Cincinnati
  • Who funds CISE
  • Who funds ENNIS TAIT MINISTRIES INC
  • Who funds TALBERT HOUSE
  • Who funds THE FIRST STEP HOME INC
  • Who funds Matthew 25 Ministries Inc
  • Who funds CINCINNATI MUSEUM ASSOCIATION
  • Who funds GEORGETOWN UNIVERSITY
  • Who funds CAMPING AND EDUCATION FOUNDATION
  • Who funds BLOC MINISTRIES INC
  • Who funds CINCINNATI USA REGIONAL CHAMBER
  • Who funds BOYS & GIRLS CLUBS OF GREATER CINCINNATI
  • Who funds LA SOUPE INC
  • Who funds International Rett Syndrome Foundation

The grantmakers whose grantees overlap with yours far more than size alone predicts. Each orbits closer the stronger the alignment; the arcs between them show where they also fund each other. Here it reads as a tightly interlocked camp — most of these funders back each other's grantees too.

The Greater Cincinnati FoundationOH86.4× affinity52 shared granteesties to 11 of 11Hover any node to trace its alignments.Compare side by side →

Open a dossier: The Greater Cincinnati Foundation · Johnson Charitable Gift Fund · Carol Ann and Ralph V Haile Jr Foundation · Robert H & Susan F Castellini Foundation · Marge & Charles J Schott Foundation · Farmer Family Foundation · The Thomas J Emery Memorial · Louise Taft Semple Foundation · John a Schroth Family Char Tr · Hcs Foundation · The James J and Joan a Gardner Family Foundation · Sutphin Family Foundation Ica

Affinity is a Gamma-Poisson posterior co-funding rate, re-centered on the typical rate, so thin evidence shrinks toward no signal. A research starting point: overlap is association, not proof of shared intent.

Government reliance of your grantees

Every dot is one organization Williams Foundation funds. Left–right is the share of its income from government; up–down is the share from you. Bigger dots raise more. Filter to federal or a single department — and drag the year to watch it move.

2024
202122232425
no gov · 20%2%6%14%25%your share of their income ↑0%10%20%30%40%share of the org’s income from governmentmedian 1%
  • The Filmmakers Collaborative Inc1% of income from government
no gov moneyreceives it· size = income
2get no government money at all
25report government grants on their 990 we could not trace to a source (not plotted)
0rely on government for over half their income
⤢ axis zoomed · 0–40%
typical government reliance, FY2025

Government income is each org’s traced federal awards (USASpending — grants and contracts) plus state payments (open checkbooks) as a share of its total revenue (IRS Form 990); the self-reported government-grant line (990 line 1e) is carried for cross-check: a grantee that reports government grants we could not trace to a source is left off the chart rather than shown as receiving none. An association, not a claim that your grant caused the public funding. Coverage is precision-first — a floor, not a census; state records exist for 9 states, so a grantee outside them shows no state figure (dimmed) rather than a false zero. Federal award amounts are obligations, which can span years, so a single-year share is indicative. 990 filings lag 12–24 months.

05Through Plinth

Warm introductions · Powered by PlinthPlus

How do I get to Williams Foundation?

Find your warmest path to Williams Foundation through trustees and officers whose names appear on both boards. Search for your organization and Plinth traces the shortest route it can evidence.

Each link is a name appearing on two organizations’ public IRS 990 filings, matched on that name and, where the filings support it, on location. A same-state match has geographic support, which is a second matching feature rather than confirmation that the two are one person; a cross-state one is the likeliest to be two people who share a name. Every hop shows its tier, low-confidence and distant paths are held back rather than guessed, and it is worth confirming the person before you use the introduction.

On method. Every financial figure here is read directly from IRS e-file XML — your own 990/990-PF and the multi-year returns of the 169 grantees we resolved across every year we hold, several hundred filings in all (a different count from the grant rows on the cover, which are one fiscal year)— each linked to its source. Grantee achievements and outcomes are each organization’s own program-service reporting (Form 990, Part III); we read these as association with sustained funding — the foundation is one of several forces — suppress low-confidence name matches rather than guess, and say so where a figure rests on a single grant or filing. Not everything on this page is a filed figure, and the difference matters. Filed is what you reported on your return. Official is another government record about an organization, such as a federal award or a charity register, joined by name where no shared identifier exists. Resolved is an identity we worked out where the filing named a recipient without an EIN, kept only above a measured confidence threshold. Computed is arithmetic over those, like themes, portfolio clusters and co-funder strength. Context is a statistic about a place rather than about an organization, which is what the need overlay is: it describes the area a grantee’s address sits in, not where its work lands. Inferred is drawn by a model from text, like the partnerships read out of public news and organization websites. Each is labeled where it appears. How we build these →

Generated from your IRS Form 990-PF e-file return for fiscal year 2024, released 2024. Filings run roughly 12–24 months behind; figures are dated accordingly.

Source object · view filing

More from the funding graph